Thanks For Coming Back! Your Free Allocated Content Will Shortly Be Coming to an End. We would like to give you a 14-Day Free Trial with No Credit Card Required.

Create a profile and unlock personalized features. Receive your personalised daily report. Login to your Personal FEED, Follow and Join Channel VIP Rooms. Comment and be part of our global community. Get access to all member content with No Censorship, Freedom of Speech, No tracking, No algorithms and NO A.I. Plus much more. Click the START button, complete the form below and verify your email address.

This offer expires in
00 00 00

Start your free trial now!
No Payment or Credit Card Required

Already a premium member? Log in here

Skip the Trial - Join Us Now

Join the Worldwide Community That Believe in the Protection of Freedom of Speech

Your Free Allocated Content Has come to an End. However, We would like to give you a 14-Day Free Trial with No Credit Card Required.

Create a profile and unlock personalized features. Receive your personalised daily report. Login to your Personal FEED, Follow and Join Channel VIP Rooms. Comment and be part of our global community. Get access to all member content with No Censorship, Freedom of Speech, No tracking, No algorithms and NO A.I. Plus much more. Click the START button, complete the form below and verify your email address.

This offer expires in
00 00 00

Start your free trial now!
No Payment or Credit Card Required

Already a premium member? Log in here

Skip the Trial - Join Us Now

Join the Worldwide Community That Believe in the Protection of Freedom of Speech

You need to log in to proceed.

Login

Read

Supreme Court reverses vaccine mandate ruling, orders $30k in costs against former NZDF personnel

  • elocal magazine By elocal magazine
  • Apr 16, 2025

The Supreme Court has overturned a Court of Appeal ruling that found the New Zealand Defence Force’s internal COVID vaccine mandate breached the Bill of Rights.

The ruling reinstated the military’s authority to discharge unvaccinated personnel and ordered four former servicemen to pay $30,000 in legal costs.

The case centred on the NZDF’s 2022 Temporary Defence Force Order (TDFO), which declared unvaccinated members “ineffectual” and made them subject to discharge without the usual procedural protections.

The applicants, all former full-time personnel, argued the mandate unjustifiably infringed their rights to refuse medical treatment and manifest belief under the Bill of Rights Act.

However, in a unanimous decision released Friday, the Supreme Court found the TDFO did not materially increase restrictions beyond earlier policies and that any added burdens were justified in light of operational needs.

The Court said decisions about readiness and discipline were within the Chief of Defence Force’s statutory mandate and expertise and that a “margin of appreciation” should be given in such cases.

Of note is the $30,000 cost order imposed on the applicants – unusual in Bill of Rights litigation, where courts often avoid deterring future challenges. Its inclusion will likely be read by critics as a warning to future dissenters.

The Human Rights Commission had intervened in the case, urging a close look at the mandate’s justification.

The Court acknowledged the seriousness of the rights involved but found the NZDF’s actions demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society.

Centrist Ltd. 

New Zealand
Current Affairs
Avatar

View elocal magazine’s premium content now…

Get a free 14 day trial (no credit card required)

Already a premium member? Log in here

Skip the Trial - Join Us Now